- Let us all react, but with compassion
- Lama Doboom Tulku
- (As told to Sudhamahi Regunathan)
AT times like these, the mind reflects. Reflections bring to fore
one's own personal sentiments and the norms accepted by society as necessary for peaceful
co-existence. If the first is hurt, it still does not matter so much. But when the second
is hurt, then the first too is necessarily hurt and the wound is very deep.
In Buddhist thought, a two-fold path is recognised: method and wisdom.
By working with and meditating in accordance with this two-fold path, one achieves the two
Bodies (kaya) of enlightenment. I do not propose here to enter into a detailed discussion
of the doctrines of the two truths nor of the two kayas. I wish to highlight just the
basic idea. From the method aspect we achieve Rupakaya or Form Body of enlightenment and
from the wisdom aspect we achieve the Dharmakaya, the Truth Body. These are final
Wrote the Buddhist master Gyalwa Genden Gyatso (the second Dalai Lama):
This then is an easily understood explanation
Of the glorious practices of higher being
That plant the imprint of the two buddhakayas.
I urge you to practice it.
The pure essence of the great Mahayana.
It is said that Dharmakaya and Rupakaya are to be obtained
simultaneously; one can not be obtained without obtaining the other. They have the
relation of the container and the contained, where Rupakaya is the container. Dharmakaya
is non-physical while Rupakaya is of the body. It is for this reason that in Buddhism
emphasis is placed on the generation of wisdom and merit, without neglecting one or the
Of the two, Rupakaya is often preferred for it is visible while
Dharmakaya is a mental attribute and may not be visible to the layman. It is also not
possible to attain Dharmakaya without attaining Rupakaya. Since the ultimate purpose of
the Bodhisattva is to serve sentient beings, Rupakaya is more useful. The Bodhisattva
dedicates whatever merit he has accumulated to the happiness of all sentient beings.
There are many artistic and ritualistic symbols of the forms of
attainment. In the present context, it is of relevance to remind the people of the
symbolism of the stupa and the statue. The symbol of Dharmakaya is the stupa. The symbol
of Rupakaya is the statue. A statue in addition to representing the physical body of the
historical Buddha also presents a symbol of the Form aspect of enlightenment. It is well
known that the manner in which the idol is represented has even more detailed symbolism.In
Buddhism, idols are not worshipped as is understood in common parlance. But Buddhists do
make offerings to statues, so that through them they make offerings to the Buddha, the
Enlightened One. In Mahayana Buddhism there are transcendental Buddhas. They are also
When I heard of the destruction of the Buddha statues in Bamiyan, the
thoughts that came to me were all the above and more. The sense of hurt was and is deep.
The hurt however does not stop there. As a Buddhist, my grief may be personal, and such
feelings may be limited to certain sections of the society. But as human beings, the grief
belongs to all of us. To all those who have been helpless witness to this atrocity. Not
everybody needs to pay respect to the Buddha. Not everybody would pay homage to an idol.
To the pilgrim, these statues represent a continuity of tradition and are a symbol of
their heritage. To the tourist they are wonderful sites to visit and take pictures of to
remember them by. Culturally they represent stages of mental evolution and the myriad
influences operating during those times. Artistically they mark a certain period in the
aesthetic development of man. All this makes the statues a global heritage, a common
cultural heritage. What hurts me most is that the action represents an attempt to erase
history. Not even a thousand golden Buddhas of the same size, made now to undo this
terrible mistake will be able to compensate the loss.
As a Buddhist I try to remind myself that all sentient beings possess
the tathagatagarbha, the essence of Buddha. One simple way of understanding the doctrine
of the tathagatagarbha, is that no matter how ferocious the being, such as a beast for
example may be, even they have the seeds of compassion in their mind. This is the seed of
Dharmakaya. It is too powerful and cannot be destroyed by any weapon. So while it is
natural that people should react to this vandalism, it is necessary to react with
compassion. Compassion, not in a passive sense but with idea of benefiting a large number
of sentient beings, mainly to prevent such atrocities from happening again. One should
think of long-term measures for preventing such a thing from happening again and not just
react in anger, to forget a few days later.